Skip to main content

602-648-3200

888-683-6835

Call us toll free

As regular readers of this blog know, there is a lot of medical malpractice out there.  It is still the third leading cause of death in the United States and has been for many years.  In spite of the large volume of medical malpractice cases, only a few ever end up being the subject of a civil suit.  The reasons for so few suits are many.  Often the patient does not know that she or he has been the victim of malpractice as the health care providers follow the old Mafia code of Omerta.  Other times they are just grateful to be alive and just want to move on.  Many times their injuries are not major ones and it makes no sense to try and bring an expensive medical malpractice action.  In any event, the one thing that almost never happens is that a negligent health care provider gets prosecuted criminally.  Based on recent news reports, I wonder if that is changing.

357653cd 8b9b 43f6 950b 69b073ef20ab

When a health care provider gets criminally prosecuted, it is usually for intentional conduct.  She or he steals drugs.  She or he files phony insurance claims.  She (but usually he) sexually assaults patients.  Rarely does a mistake result in criminal prosecution.  Prosecutors know that these cases are usually losers for them and properly don’t want to waste their valuable resources or tarnish their reputations as winners in court so they don’t bring charges in the first place.

Why are these cases usually losers?  Juries understand that doctors and nurses are only human.  If they are trying to do the right thing and just make a mistake, juries have a lot of sympathy for them and do not want to send them to jail.  Smart defense lawyers suggest that if doctors and nurses are held criminally liable, no one will want to be a doctor or nurse and care for the public.  It is an unsurprisingly effective argument.

Sometimes though the publicity surrounding a mistake, or especially a series of mistakes, is such that a prosecutor may feel she or he has more to lose if they don’t file criminal charges than if they do.  Also they recognize that a charge filed now when the spotlight is hot can be quietly dismissed or pled down when things cool down in a few months.

For example, it will be interesting to see how the State of Tennessee handles the uproar over the hospital pharmacy error that led to four people being given potassium instead of an antibiotic prior to surgery.  One of the patients has been declared brain dead and the other three have varying degrees of paraplegia.  The push to exact punishment will be very strong.

A similar case in Tennessee from only four years ago may provide some insight.  A nurse was ordered to give a patient a sedative prior to a scanning procedure.  The hospital in which this occurred had an automatic dispensing machine for medications so the nurses did not have to go to the pharmacy to get the medications they needed.  The nurse had to type the name of the medication into the machine and it would dispense the medication.  To save time, the manufacturer had designed the machine to offer alternatives after only the first two letters of the name were entered.  When the nurse typed in the first two letters of the name of the sedative, the machine offered her a choice of medications, the top one of which was a highly dangerous paralytic agent whose name started with the same two letters as the sedative she was seekng.  The nurse mistakenly selected the first medication on the list and administered it to the patient.  When someone came to take the patient to her scan, she was brain dead.  The nurse was charged with reckless homicide and criminally negligent homicide.  The jury acquitted her on the first count but convicted her on the second.  She was sentenced to three years of supervised probation.

In a notorious case, a Texas neurosurgeon was charged, tried and convicted of elder abuse and sentenced to life in prison.  Sounds bad, doesn’t it?  The back story is that the neurosurgeon operated on 35 patients in his career and either paralyzed or killed all but three.  It was stupefying how bad a surgeon he was.  He was not trying to injure anyone but was just a complete and total incompetent.  The people who should have been sent to jail for his mistakes were the hospital executives who recognized his utter lack of qualifications and failed to report him to the Texas Medical Board.  Instead, they sent him on down the road and never warned the next hospital he went to about his problems.  At least three hospitals did this and none got in any trouble.  That was the real crime here.

Three nurses in Colorado were charged with criminally negligent homicide in the death of a one-day old infant who was given a massive overdose of penicillin.  Two of the nurses accepted plea bargains to avoid prison time.  The third chose to go to trial where she was acquitted of all charges.

More cases are beginning to appear in the news.  As hospital chains grow ever larger and more and more doctors become employees of these large chains, patients feel less connected to their doctors than in years past.  This is having an effect on malpractice verdicts and may have an effect on the willingness of juries to convict doctors and nurses.  Time will tell.